Dec 15, 2011 why did luc besson turn joan of arc into an irritating brat. This is a borderline case, however, as more than one interpretation is offered for the visions, and indeed implied for the conscience. Neither was the first attempt to film the life of the. Luc besson has constructed a movie that is ambitious and inspiring, with no room for the compromising or modest. History in film reel american history films list lehigh university. The story of joan of arc stars milla jovovich as joan of arc, faye dunaway as yolande daragon, and dustin hoffman as the grand inquisitor. In contrast, luc besson, director of the messenger. The scene in which joan witnesses her sisters murder and posthumous rape by english soldiers in. Not content with ignoring the facts, the film invents its own. For example, joans sister is murdered and then raped.
Milla jovovich the fifth element, dazed and confused is joan of arc, a young woman who would inspire and lead her countrymen until her execution at the age of nineteen. Also sign me up for fanmail to get updates on all things movies. Joan of arc, if the portrayals were accurate was a driven young woman, deeply religious and deeply confused who was probably at least partially insane. Centuries later, joan of arc was canonized as a saint of the roman catholic church. I have read and seen many documentaries about joan of arc and never heard of any rape taking place, which leads me to believe that this did not happen. The story of joan of arc i suppose i should know better than to present a historians view of a film of this sort, but such is what i do. I especially like the way they incorporated so many of joan s most famous quotes into the script. In may 1428, joan made her way to vaucouleurs, a nearby stronghold of those loyal to charles. The film stars milla jovovich, john malkovich, faye dunaway and dustin hoffman. The battles 1994, the trial of joan of arc 1962 and jeannette. What is the most historically accurate portrayal of joan. Milla jovovich certainly has the crazed intensity of a zealot. Jan 02, 2014 in 1429, a 16yearold girl from a remote village stood before the world and announced she would defeat the worlds greatest army and liberate her country.
The story of joan of arc labors under the misapprehension that joans life is a war story and takes place largely on battlefields. Why did luc besson turn joan of arc into an irritating brat. Whether joan saw god and was his messenger, or simply suffered from some sort of delusional psychosis. Joan of arc milla jovovich is the teenage warrior leading the fight against the english. If i were to continue with the historical misrepresentations and falsifications of the facts. T he messenger is a film i admit i have not seen, and probably wont see after observing the negative thoughts from various christian moviegoers. The film has the potential of sparking interest in the subject. Jeanne darc is a 1999 french epic historical drama film directed by luc besson. Milla jovovich, john malkovich, rab affleck the messenger. What is the most historically accurate portrayal of joan of.
Her constant compulsion to confess her sins, and her visions of god, seemed realistic. A list of 12 films compiled on letterboxd, including the passion of joan of arc 1928, joan the maid ii. Joan runs to her home village and sees that the english are torching it and we hear people screaming and see dead or injured villagers. The story of joan of arc the messenger is a movie cowritten and directed by the french director luc besson in 1999. The story of joan of arc comes to bluray from sony pictures home entertainment. In terms of story, this does a good job at telling joan of arcs story, but it is not accurate either.
Joan of arc is a 1948 american hagiographic epic film directed by victor fleming, and starring ingrid bergman as the french religious icon and war heroine. The story of joan of arc stars milla jovovich, john malkovich, faye dunaway, dustin hoffman the r movie has a runtime of about 2 hr 28 min, and. Instead, i want to draw attention to a worthy alternative. Joan of arc, a canadian television production directed by christian duguay and starring leelee sobieski, was broadcast on cbs in may 1999. Leading lady caitlin deerin was, at the time of filming, exactly the same age. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can reassess it. This said, the central question of whether she was a saint, an inspired lunatic, wholly mentally ill, or simply a headstrong girl determined to grab her chances while she could is well asked. Some friends were concerned about both the dogma and history in the new movie by french director luc besson titled the messenger. Enter your location to see which movie theaters are playing the messenger. Critics love this movie, but i admit i felt sleepy watching it. Feb 01, 2000 in may 1999, cbs aired a fourhour miniseries entitled joan of arc, starring teenaged leelee sobieski.
This movie, the messenger joan of arc, is simply one of my favorites, with great. The story of joan of arc for flashy french director luc besson, joan of arcs story is just another excuse to play with a whole new set of toys. Besson means well with the messenger, and there are some interesting ideas in the film, but overall its not one of his stronger efforts. Ignatius press has recently released this movie to dvd and i am going to tell you a little bit about it. This unusual french interpretation of joan of arc sees her as a radical zealot like john brown. Although luc besson tries to minimize the importance of this fact. The treaty states that the kingdom of france will belong to england upon the kings death. There are many deviations from the accepted facts of jeanne darcs life as set out in her trial documentation and the writings of the time. Ive seen bits of it, and it seemed nice enough, but doesnt seem to be highly regarded. The french ecclesiastics delegated by the occupying english power to the thankless chore of determining whether joan of arc was an imposter or a heretic guided by satan would love the messenger. The story of joan of arc, the famous historical figure, joan of arc, battles the english soldiers who took over northern france in the 1400s. Raised in a religious family, joan witnessed her sisters rape and death at the hands of an invading army. Jun 09, 2016 ignatius press has recently released this movie to dvd and i am going to tell you a little bit about it.
Eight nominations for the french academy awards, but the film won only two of them best costume design and best sound. This is luc bessons grand take on the heroine joan of arc with lots of gusto. Joan of arc maid of heaven joan of arc books, movies. There are many deviations from the accepted facts of jeanne d arc s life as set out in her trial documentation and the writings of the time. The story of joan of arc, directed by luc besson and starring milla jovovich. In 1429, a 16yearold girl from a remote village stood before the world and announced she would defeat the worlds greatest army and liberate her country.
The story of joan of arc 1999 mystic, maiden, martyr whatever you choose to call her, it is difficult to dispute that joan of arc led a remarkably accomplished life for a. In may 1999, cbs aired a fourhour miniseries entitled joan of arc, starring. The story of joan of arc, directed by luc besson and starring the exmodel and sometime rock singer milla jovovich. Leading lady caitlin deerin was, at the time of filming, exactly the same age joan of arc was at the beginning of her mission. Its also far from the best movie made on this subject.
These are the films ive seen for the project, ranked in. Im writing a grad school paper on the filmic depictions of joan of arc. Firstly, the messenger included unnecessary violence. If she were alive today, no doubt, she would be treated with common drugs and would lead a normal life.
Henry v, king of england, and charles vi, king of france, sign the treaty of troyes. The story of joan of arc you are looking for epic, captivating and factual movies about with battles, politics, joan of arc, war, heroic mission, siege and courage themes of adventure, biography and drama genre shot in france or czech republic. During englands occupation of france during the hundred years war a young. The story of joan of arc is a powerful historical epic from director luc besson.
It is based on maxwell andersons successful broadway play joan of lorraine, which also starred bergman, and was adapted for the screen by anderson himself, in collaboration with andrew solt. The story of joan of arc is, for the most part, a largely orchestral score, supplemented with some synth effects. In fact, it takes place almost entirely within the consciences of everyone involved. The messenger 1999 staring his thenwife milla jovovich is only the most recent film. Luc besson rounds out the corpus with his stylistic and vaguely heretical grandscale feature, the messenger. Leelee sobieski plays the title role with other big names filling out the cast including peter otoole, jacqueline. We are ushered into luc bessons joan of arc biopic by portentous captions informing us that it is going to take a miracle to save the depressed, riven, warravaged france of the 15th century. One of the modern criticisms of the film is that bergman, who was 33 at the time she made the movie, was nearly twice as old as the real joan of arc. I had already heard about the new look of the maid of orleans whose. The story of joan of arc if youre going to do joan of arc, it helps to have an actress to play the leading role. The movie does at least concede that a good part of joans legend involves her trial for heresy and her burning at the stake, and these scenes may. The story of joan of arc has been listed as one of the media and drama good articles under the good article criteria.
This movie is one of very few in cinematic history to have joan of arc played by an actual teenager. Joan of arc maid of heaven joan of arc books, movies and. Of course, since joan of arc was definitely a real person, the messenger might also be accused of going the opposite route and adding fantastic elements though this gets into a tricky theological debate. The movies focus is firmly on her years of prominence as a military and inspirational figure. The movie does at least concede that a good part of joans legend involves her trial for heresy and her burning at the stake, and these scenes. Jeanne d arc is a 1999 french epic historical drama film directed by luc besson.
The story of joan of arc 1999 official trailer 1 milla jovovich movie a young girl receives a vision that drives her to rid. So, if you enjoy overblown periodpiece spectacles with no consistency of tone or theme, rush thee out to see the messenger. It begins with the child joan witnessing the brutal murder and rape in that order of her. Leelee sobieski plays the title role with other big names filling out the cast including peter otoole, jacqueline bisset, shirley maclaine, and neil patrick harris. The screenplay was written by besson and andrew birkin, and the original music score was composed by eric serra. After much success, allegedly led by visions and voices from god, joan is captured by some collaborators. A crass and interminable movie that miraculously transforms one of the most remarkable women of the.
There are many deviations from the accepted facts of jeanne darcs life as. After much success, allegedly led by visions and voices from god, joan is captured by some collaborators, who turn her over to the english authorities. The story of joan of arc, and thats essentially what it purports to tell, but dont mistake it for a biodrama. Directed by luc besson, the messenger was originally titled joan of arc but added the prefix to avoid confusion with the 1999 tv movie of the same name, which starred leelee sobieski. The movie does at least concede that a good part of joans legend involves her trial for heresy and her burning at the stake, and these. I thought the film portrayed joan of arc as she would have likely been. The story of joan of arc is a serious dramatic tragedy, and it takes itself as that all of the time. Previous scores by serra have primarily been synth heavy, and it was very interesting to hear his approach to using a large orchestra and chorus. Like the books the movie versions contribute varying portrayals that reflect the values of their time rather than the reality.
899 1558 689 1109 1546 194 1329 854 1412 573 1319 1361 672 617 142 1367 415 285 961 1233 705 324 912 693 936 403 1197 212 122 709 1198 503 787 917 929 977 917 1029 907 295 869